• Guide to positions
  • Study in Germany
  • PhD in Germany
  • Postdoc in Germany
  • Professor in Germany
  • Industry guide
  • Research & Development in Germany
  • Engineering in Germany
  • Thematic guide
  • Working in Germany
  • Working in Austria
  • Working in Switzerland
  • Higher education in Germany
  • Job profiles
  • Service range
  • Events
  • Employers
  • Graduate schools
  • Guide overview
Extended job search
Study in Germany PhD in Germany Postdoc in Germany Professor in Germany
Research & Development in Germany Engineering in Germany
Working in Germany Working in Austria Working in Switzerland Higher education in Germany Job profiles
Events Employers Graduate schools Guide overview
Log in Bookmarks For employers
academics - Logo
From
Die ZEIT - Logo
Forschung & Lehre - Logo
Career advice My academics Log in Bookmarks (0) Bookmarks For employers

Engineering degrees Germany
The differences between German and Chinese degrees in engineering

The training of engineers at German universities enjoys high regard internationally. In comparison with engineering training in China, it is far more hands-on. Do the differences in the degree systems also lead to better qualified or less well-qualified engineers?

What are the differences between German and Chinese degrees in engineering? © Michael Schnell / photocase.de

Forschung & Lehre: Chairman of Festo AG, Dr. Eberhard Veit, recently stated that a German engineer is still better than a Chinese one. Chinese engineers are "crammed with theory at the universities. There are lectures in the truest sense of the word there - questions are not permitted. Practical experience and lab work are often lacking". Do you share this belief? Are German engineers better trained? 

Reinhart Poprawe: Yes, there are differences, though I cannot agree with this across the board. Our students, who participated in the double Master's programme at the RWTH Aachen and Tsinghua University, reported that they were able to make few friends, for example. The social cohesion among students is obviously far greater here despite the growing competitive pressure. The training in Germany is also undoubtedly more hands-on. Engineers experience and learn of the social relevance early on through the more or less strategic integration of training and research. 

F&L: How great are the differences between the engineering training really? What are the most important differences? 

Reinhart Poprawe: Germany earns more than one quarter of its gross national product with the production of goods. This corporate culture of fostering young academic talent with a practical approach from the universities has long dominated. The research topics whose fundamental publishable findings are then literally integrated into the current training are often oriented towards these questions. The state tender-based funding of research on state and national levels works in complement as a catalyst for industry-defined research projects. Hence a circle of implementation and innovation-oriented research links with the current training. China is not (yet) familiar with this. But even if it turns out the same with Humboldt as it did with Karl Marx that the Chinese adaptation of German thinkers leads to sustainable benefits in the country, this will not be a disadvantage of us. The esteem for the initiator would open a great many doors here and create opportunities. 


F&L: What value does the training have at Chinese universities?

Reinhart Poprawe: Few differences are discernible. Training - and thereby the highest quality training in the country - is and remains a prominent primary task of the universities. In the past few decades, research has increasingly been added to this though. Where the technical-natural science Nobel Prizes were once often earned in the research labs of major industry (e.g. Bell Labs), the focus today has shifted. And particularly the integration of demanding, practical research into the training leads to innovation-capable young academics. The Fraunhofer Society's principle is today considered a benchmark in this around the globe, and we can be pleased and proud of our forefathers, who already recognised this principle and its relevance for innovation over 60 years ago in Germany. 

F&L: Is the German diploma recognised and acknowledged as a brand in China? 

Reinhart Poprawe: It certainly is. 

Don't miss out on any new jobs

With our Job-Mail, you will receive suitable job ads as well as interesting content matching your search profile on a weekly basis.

Please enter an email address in a valid format.
You can stop your Job-Mail subscription at any time, e.g. by sending an email to info@academics.com. We also use your email address to send you advertisements for similar offers from the ZEIT publishing group. You can withdraw your consent to this use at any time. By registering, you declare your agreement with our terms & conditions and take note of our privacy policy.

F&L: To what extend must a German professor teaching at a Chinese university adapt to the Chinese system of study? Can they bring their teaching methods with them, so to speak? 

Reinhart Poprawe: This question doesn't actually come up. They can and will use their curricula as they have developed them. They also cannot change their methods overnight. Interesting is the question of how Chinese students react to it. The answer - the quote here would be "private communication" - is simple: the young people react accordingly, i.e. they see the 'other', adapt unprompted, and ask question after question after question ... - in an entirely un-Chinese fashion. 

F&L: Do German engineers tend to be recruited by German companies in China as they are better trained, or are Chinese applicants preferred as they are more familiar with the Chinese market and prepared to work for less? 

Reinhart Poprawe:You will have to put that question to Chinese and German companies, but what we heard from both categories is not clear. There are smaller branch offices in China that are 100 per cent foreign-owned and have 100 per cent Chinese engineers and employees, and other, larger companies that favour German engineers. But the tendency is currently more towards Chinese employees with the argument that they understand the clients better - not only in terms of culture but also in terms of language, as barely any medium-sized companies speak English. It seems important to me here that the German companies are currently undergoing a paradigm change: not many months ago, there was an economic bogeyman image of China; the fear of loss by the training Chinese competition dominated. Today the picture is a different one: the absolute majority of our partners and customers in the field of research see a market and potential partnership in Chinese companies. Win-win is the order of the day. 

Authors
Reinhart Poprawe
Source
Forschung & Lehre - May 2012

Share
Current job vacancies from the fields of science and research
  • PhD position "Polar climate change and mesoscale sea ice and ocean processes" (m/f/d) - 23/7/D/Kli-b

    2023-01-16 Alfred-Wegener-Institut (AWI) - Helmholtz Zentrum für Polar- und Meeresforschung Bremerhaven
    PhD position "Polar climate change and mesoscale sea ice and ocean processes" (m/f/d) - 23/7/D/Kli-b - Alfred-Wegener-Institut (AWI) - Helmholtz Zentrum für Polar- und Meeresforschung - Logo
  • Junior Professor of Polymers for Electro-Optical and Sensor Applications

    2022-12-23 Universität Bayreuth / University of Bayreuth Bayreuth
    Junior Professor of Polymers for Electro-Optical and Sensor Applications - Universität Bayreuth / University of Bayreuth - Logo
  • University Professor of the History of Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages

    2023-01-10 Freie Universität Berlin Berlin
    University Professor of the History of Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages - Freie Universität Berlin - Logo
To all job vacancies

Related articles

What physicists earn: Salary and influencing factors

Physicists working in the private sector can expect a salary significantly higher than average. If physicists remain in teaching and research, diverse opportunities are available, but are associated with a fairly average income.

Salaries in the natural sciences

Researchers and developers have the best prospects of a good salary if they choose a career in industry. An analysis of the current salary levels.

Dresden - the German Florence

Dresden is home to traditional economic sectors, new growth industries and a diverse range of higher education and research institutions.

Salary professor – what does a professor earn in Germany?

Professors and junior professors receive their salary on the basis of the W salary scale. Their basic salary varies in each federal state. They may also be eligible for performance bonuses, which must be negotiated skillfully.

Academics
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Legal notice
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies & Tracking
  • Partners
  • Job-Mail
  • academics.de
  • academics.at
  • academics.ch
For Employers
  • Post a job
  • Mediapack
  • Terms and conditions
You can also visit us at
academics - Logo From Die ZEIT - Logo Forschung & Lehre - Logo Deutscher Hochschulverband
Data privacy
Please deactivate your ad-block plugins to edit your permissions regarding cookies and tracking.