• Guide to positions
  • Study in Germany
  • PhD in Germany
  • Postdoc in Germany
  • Professor in Germany
  • Industry guide
  • Research & Development in Germany
  • Engineering in Germany
  • Thematic guide
  • Working in Germany
  • Working in Austria
  • Working in Switzerland
  • Higher education in Germany
  • Job profiles
  • Service range
  • Events
  • Employers
  • Graduate schools
  • Guide overview
Extended job search
Study in Germany PhD in Germany Postdoc in Germany Professor in Germany
Research & Development in Germany Engineering in Germany
Working in Germany Working in Austria Working in Switzerland Higher education in Germany Job profiles
Events Employers Graduate schools Guide overview
Log in Bookmarks (0) Post a job
academics - Logo
From
Die ZEIT - Logo
Forschung & Lehre - Logo
Career advice Log in Bookmarks (0) Post a job

British universities
How German and British universities can learn from one another

British universities are regarded in Germany as the benchmark for all reforms. This is absurd.

Where are the differences between german and british universities? © John Robert Marasigan / unsplash.com
Contents

When British philosophy student Kate, 23, tells Germans about her academic dream destination, she is greeted with uncomprehending looks: "What? Germany?" - "Yes, Germany." Kate's wish sounds paradoxical. Overzealous education reformers want to introduce to Germany a university system that they regard as exemplary and efficient: the Anglo-American system. However, since her year abroad, Kate longs to return to this idiosyncratic country where you have to find your own approach to ideas. She wants to study for her doctorate there and be able to thoroughly and unhurriedly explore complicated concepts regarding the decline of civilisation, Karl Popper's attacks on totalitarian philosophies and current positions vis-à-vis the much-discussed "battle of the cultures". The United Kingdom is in fact the wrong template for Germany's reforms. Its universities are not faring any better than our own. Great Britain's universities have developed into education factories. The only thing they have in common with the campus idylls behind the ivy-covered walls of Oxbridge is the scenery. Since the Thatcher era and increasingly with the Labour government, the workings of the academic machine have been characterised by three trends: firstly the growing under-financing of the universities, secondly the pampering of the "customers", i.e. the fee-paying students, regarded as the means to help the universities out of their financial misery, and thirdly the bureaucratic quality control of their personnel, known as micromanagement. Great Britain is selling off its academic family silver in order to position itself in the top rankings of the academic world market. We are among the credulous buyers in the junk market for academic prestige.


The tightening of the purse strings from the Thatcher era continues

But British universities like German universities are primarily financed by state grants and are groaning under a mountain of debt. Although British universities have slimmed down their expenditure considerably, the tightening of the purse strings that began in the Thatcher era in the eighties continues. Like their German colleagues, British university managers therefore tailor their ambitious academic plans to the interests of various financial backers. They organise their own events to solicit donations from alumni, hire out lecture halls and seminar rooms and chase after third-party funding and tuition fees.

The lofty goal of the British government to bestow university education on 50 percent of a year group significantly expands the foraging ground. Student numbers and tuition fees are increasing faster than in Germany. While European students paid 1,000 euros for a Batchelor's degree a few years ago, they now pay over 4,000 euros. Overseas students, Asians and Americans, have to shell out more than three times as much and are therefore accepted in preference, as long as they are suitable for the course.

British universities, like German universities, are also expanding their academic foraging ground with new Master's and doctorate programmes. Unlike in Germany, however, one criterion counts above all others: marketability. Programmes with a practical orientation such as Asian or European Studies are some of the biggest sellers on the market for academic courses. These create a short-lived academic landscape where knowledge goes out of date quickly.

The hard-working student elite have become customers wanting to buy new products and a comprehensive service. With the emphasis very much on pampering, the customers are mollycoddled from the taster course right through to the exam.

The name of the game is "school-like" regimentation - as has been the case in Germany since the introduction of Bachelor's and Master's courses. Nothing is left to chance. Most courses have been "on the books" for decades and tried and tested on numerous generations of students. Essay subjects are pre-defined, exams rehearsed. A regimented system like this guarantees that no one fails - and promotes academic mediocrity.

The result is streamlined pragmatism. The Bachelor's degree prepares students for a career in a non-academic sphere. A historic reason for this pragmatism is that the British have no concept of the German idea of "Bildung", which means all-round education, not just formal learning. The institution and its traditions are also paramount and the individual has to function within this framework. Although this does require initiative and research-based learning, these qualities are rarely nurtured, except for instance in the weekly one-hour tutorial that is still the norm at Oxbridge, though even this has now become a subject of controversy.

British universities are not the only ones to have their future plans threatened by pampering and consumer mentality - we in Germany are about to come up against the very same problems that Britain now faces. Having completed their Batchelor's degree, how can students then be motivated to apply themselves to a Master's degree or even a Ph.D. (doctorate)? And how are they to pay for it? Having spent a lot of money on a Bachelor's degree, people are bound to wonder whether they should invest still more in an academic qualification that - apart from a Master's in economics or law - will only be useful to them in the world of academia.

British teaching staff are grappling with questions like these, whenever they can still find the time to address them. The image of the British scholar, half gentleman, half academic, is a thing of the past. Like German academics, British university tutors are administrators, appraisers, project managers and publicists rolled into one. Their performance is carefully monitored every year internally within their university. Their salary and position depend on the results of their performance evaluation with regard to research, teaching and administration.

Every eight years, they also have to undergo the state-run research and teaching assessment exercises. These are structured differently from the appraisals within the German Initiative for Excellence. The exercises extend across all British institutes, are hugely costly and time-consuming, and form the basis for distributing considerable sums of public money according to a graded scale. Although these exercises guarantee the visibility of the high-performing new generation of academics and ensure dynamic further development in research and teaching, criticism of them is growing. The exercises control academia from above, tie up human resources and lead to special business cycles that are alien to the academic world when it comes to meetings, publications and study programmes.

Don't miss out on any new jobs

With our job newsletter, you will receive suitable job ads as well as interesting content matching your search profile on a weekly basis.

Please enter an email address in a valid format.
You can stop your newsletter subscription at any time, e.g. by sending an email to info@academics.com. We also use your email address to send you advertisements for similar offers from the ZEIT publishing group. You can withdraw your consent to this use at any time. By registering, you declare your agreement with our terms & conditions and take note of our privacy policy.

Germans and Britons can learn from each other

Although the market-oriented British system currently has the upper hand in international rankings, a strong dose of Humboldt would do it the world of good. The German university system, for its part, can only recover if it redefines Humboldt's market value. Students of today are used to networked thinking in a digital Nirvana - ideal conditions for independent experiments exploring nature, technology and the psyche.

We need to learn from each other! The best university system of all lies somewhere in between the British Isles and the Continent, in a shared European future. Unlike Germany's large-scale universities, British universities still offer small courses and have flat hierarchies and the shrinking remnants of a debate-friendly culture. The strengths of German universities lie in the interplay between research and teaching. These strengths are all-round education and initiative - values that, sadly, are currently not highly prized because they cannot be regulated. If we don't want to ultimately reform these values entirely out of existence, we should distance ourselves from ultra-perfectionist evaluations, make our universities less "school-like" and promote the independence of universities of applied sciences as well as training for professions. Only if we develop the strengths of our much-berated system according to a European vision of further education will we have an opportunity to polish up our academic family silver for the competitive global knowledge market.


About the author

Sandra Richter, 34, Professorin für Neuere Deutsche Literatur an der Universität Stuttgart, war bis 2007 Professor of German am King's College in London

Authors
Sandra Richter
Source
academics - August 2008

Share
Current job vacancies from the fields of science and research
  • Research associate (m/f/d) in the field of physics, physical engineering, electrical engineering, mechanical engineering or a comparable discipline

    2022-04-27 Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM) Berlin-Steglitz
    Research associate (m/f/d) in the field of physics, physical engineering, electrical engineering, mechanical engineering or a comparable discipline - Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM) - Logo
  • PhD Position (m/f/div) in Human Psychophysics with TMS and/or EEG

    2022-05-04 Max-Planck-Institut für biologische Kybernetik / Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics Tübingen
    PhD Position (m/f/div) in Human Psychophysics with TMS and/or EEG - Max-Planck-Institut für biologische Kybernetik / Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics - Logo
  • Endowed Junior Professorship (W1) with Tenure Track to Full Professorship (W3) in the Area of Applied polymer physics

    2022-04-06 Technische Universität Hamburg (TUHH) / Hamburg University of Technology (TUHH) Hamburg
    Endowed Junior Professorship (W1) with Tenure Track to Full Professorship (W3) in the Area of Applied polymer physics - Technische Universität Hamburg (TUHH) / Hamburg University of Technology (TUHH) - Logo
To all job vacancies

Related articles

Postdoc fellowships & funding grants

Which scholarships and funding programmes for postdocs are available in Germany? And under what circumstances are they granted? An overview.

Professional spotlight: academic manager

The profession of academic manager is growing in significance: they manage, control and organise the universities and research institutions. However, in many places, they must still fight for recognition.

Visas, residence permits and work permits for Austria

Austria is an attractive country for visiting students or researchers to work, but their rules surrounding residency and permission to work can appear complex and bureaucratic. This article provides information about how you can meet these requirements.

Dresden - the German Florence

Dresden is home to traditional economic sectors, new growth industries and a diverse range of higher education and research institutions.

Academics
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Legal notice
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies & Tracking
  • Partners
  • Jobnewsletter
  • academics.de
  • academics.at
  • academics.ch
For Employers
  • Post a job
  • Mediapack (PDF)
  • Terms and conditions
You can also visit us at
academics - Logo From Die ZEIT - Logo Forschung & Lehre - Logo Deutscher Hochschulverband
Data privacy
Please deactivate your ad-block plugins to edit your permissions regarding cookies and tracking.